Senators Report Card: Who's Making the Grade?
The Ottawa Senators are off to their third-best start in franchise history. Alex Adams hands out his quarter-season grades, from the team's biggest standouts to those who need to step up.

In this story
12 playersThe Ottawa Senators are rolling with their third-best record ever through 22 games.
Life is good in Senators’ land right now.
So, let’s have some fun, shall we?
It’s the quarter season mark, and we thought it would be a good idea to take a step back to give out letter grades.
Forwards
Tim Stutzle: A
The Senators wouldn’t be where they are without Tim Stutzle. He’s done a lot of heavy lifting offensively. He’s on pace for career highs in every offensive category. He’s become an excellent two-way centre who kills penalties effectively, too. Many wondered if he could make the jump to become world class. He’s done that. The only reason he’s not an A+ is because the power play of which he’s a part of has struggled.
Drake Batherson: A-
There were worries whether Drake Batherson could carry the mantle of the highest paid Senator of all time. The optimists would focus on Batherson’s ability to improve his offensive output every season of his career. Well, currently he’s on pace to do that again. Stiil, like Stutzle, he is chasing quality over quantity on the power play with disappointing results.
Dylan Cozens: C
When a centre gets moved to the wing, it’s rarely a good sign. Cozens only has four goals in 22 games. The Yukoner has admitted to his production being not good enough. It’s led to him changing sticks, searching for that perfect blade that will improve his performance. In the meantime, he’s been demoted from the first power play unit-- where he scored 13 of his 28 goals last season. Simply put, the Senators need a better Dylan Cozens whether it’s on the wing or at centre.
Shane Pinto: A
Until this season, despite his excellence in a shut-down role on the third line, we never knew whether Pinto could be a good second line centre. Since Travis Green elevated him to the second line centre on Halloween, he’s been excellent, tallying eight points in eight games. The second line of Pinto, Philip Tomasino and Batherson have an expected goals share of 56 per cent while outscoring opponents four to two. Not to mention Pinto has set up or scored big goals lately versus L.A., Utah, Buffalo, and Colorado.
At one point this summer, Claude Giroux was reportedly joining the Flyers. Instead, he decided to stay home and become one of the best third liners in the league. Giroux, already a renowned faceoff artist, is winning them at the highest rate of his career. His connection with Michael Amadio, and centres Ridly Greig or Pinto has been fun to watch. As Green said in camp, Giroux looks 25 again and he’s playing like it.
Michael Amadio: A+
As Jason York says, he’s playing chess while others are playing checkers. The cerebral Amadio is having a career year which happens also to be a contract year. The price of the brick is only going upwards for Amadio. His ability to neutralize opponents and turn pucks over with his stick is amongst the best in the NHL. His uptick in offensive production has been welcomed by a Senators club that struggles to finish at times.
Ridly Greig: A
Ridly Greig leads the league in drawn penalties, and annoying opponents. He’s “just being idiots” with his linemates Giroux and Amadio, but effective at it. The trio has been dominant thus far this season, and Greig’s shown he can be a more than capable third line centre.
Zetterlund hasn’t looked out of place alongside Stutzle on the first line. However, he hasn’t been lighting it up either. Like Cozens, his nine points this season is fine but could be better. When William Eklund returns, we are unsure where Zetterlund fits in the lineup.
Stephen Halliday: C+
Most fourth line centres wouldn’t even sniff the first power play unit. Halliday isn’t your typical fourth liner. His mix of skill and vision, has provided good secondary offence with eight points. However, at five-on-five he’s struggled to drive play.
William Eklund: incomplete
Looked dynamic, creative and a play driver in the three games before his injury.
Warren Foegele: C+
Foegele is a north-south player who looked to be playing well before a scary leg injury in Vegas. The former 20-goal scorer hadn’t been replicating that play to begin the season, but the Senators need that scoring punch.
Nick Cousins: C
Cousins has struggled at times even in a fourth line role. However, his play had been improving and the game-winning goal against Utah exemplified that.
Andre Burakovsky: F
The Burakovsky experiment has not worked. Three shots in eight games, none in the slot. Time to move on, which reportedly the Senators are trying to do.
Philip Tomasino: B+
Tomasino has been an adequate top-six option amidst the injuries up front. Nothing flashy, and defensively he can be exposed, but he’s not dragging his linemates Pinto or Batherson down.
Other notable incompletes: Boucher, Blais, Bourgeault , Hodgson
Defence
Jake Sanderson: A-
Graeme Nichols’ piece on Sanderson explains the before and after effects of Sanderson's presence in the Senators lineup. With Sanderson, the Senators are a top-10 team in the league at five-on-five; without him this season they’ve been bottom 10. On the downside, he’s struggled quarterbacking the power play and his offensive production has slowed. Nevertheless, Sanderson swims in the same waters as Cale Makar and Quinn Hughes in terms of how he's able to impact a game.
Artem Zub: B
Zub has been solid this season but has been uncharacteristically shaky on the puck at times. In a contract season, his partnership with Sanderson has been very good but not as good as last season. It’s still early, and Zub is a mainstay, but at 31 years old, with limited offensive capabilities, it will present the Senators a tough decision to make. Whether to extend Zub into his thirties which is a risk or move on but lose an integral part of the lineup.
Thomas Chabot: A-
2026 has been a banner year for Chabot, becoming a father and captain. Chabot is anchoring one of the best pairs in the league alongside Jordan Spence. Unlike the previous captain, he presents no distractions. The Senators are off to their best record in over a decade and Chabot is leading that charge. It’s a new era in Ottawa.
Jordan Spence: A
Why the L.A. Kings let go of Jordan Spence, we’ll never know. Spence has been dominant when playing with Chabot, together providing the third-best expected goal share at five-on-five of any pair that’s played 200 minutes this season. At five-on-five with them on the ice, the Senators have outscored opponents 17 to six. Spence is an analytics darling: the only quibble is that he’s shown little offence so far.
Tyler Kleven: B
In the past two seasons, Kleven has started slow. This season, he’s played the part of a rangy, physical third pair defenceman. Kleven is fifth in the league with 51 block shots. He’s rekindled an efficient partnership with Nikolas Matinpalo. Plus, when tasked with an elevated role with Chabot and Sanderson out, Kleven was a stable, solid presence.
Nikolas Matinpalo: B+
The reason why Carter Yakemchuk is so often healthy scratched has as much to do with Matinpalo as Yakemchuk. With his excellent skating, size and strength Mantinpalo has become a full-time third pairing defensive stalwart. His play on the puck will always hold him back, but he continues to munch minutes well.
Carter Yakemchuk: C-
It’s a fair question to ask whether Yakemchuk needs to go back to Belleville. In insulated minutes, Yakemchuk hasn’t produced enough flashes of offence which is his strength. In the meantime, he’s constantly hemmed into his own zone.
Goalies
Linus Ullmark: A+
Linus Ullmark's story has been admirable on and off the ice. Since getting help for panic attacks and his mental health struggles early in 2026, he’s become dominant. If he can stay healthy this season, winning his second Vezina is a real possibility. The stats that jump out are his 10-1-0 record with the best goals saved above expected per 60 minutes in the league. If Ullmark sustains anything close to this level, the Senators can morph into Cup contenders.
Sam Ersson: B-
After a shaky start on the second night of back-to-backs, Ersson has settled in. His .885 save percentage is essentially league average. Bang average is exactly what Staios wanted heading into the season, and Ersson has done it.
Coach/Management
Travis Green: A
Green deserves Jack Adams buzz. Outside of the power play, the team has bought into his system and executed on it.
Steve Staios: A-
The Burakovsky choice was a swing and a miss, but not a crippling one. Staios proved right in his decision to trade Tkachuk immediately and avoid the situations that developed in Winnipeg and Detroit with their disgruntled stars. The Senators have the sixth best record thus far and Staios deserves a chunk of the credit.
