The Pros and Cons of Bringing Erik Karlsson Back to Ottawa
With the Senators among the NHL's top teams, would a reunion with their former captain help Ottawa's Stanley Cup ambitions or do more harm than good?

In this story
8 players“My heart wants Karlsson back, my head says no.”
That's how one Senators fan described the possibility of Erik Karlsson returning to Ottawa.
And it might be the perfect way to sum up the debate.
Who wouldn't want to see one of the greatest players in franchise history back in a Senators uniform?
But would bringing back the three-time Norris Trophy winner actually make Ottawa a better hockey team?
It's a question worth asking after Senators general manager Steve Staios was spotted watching the Pittsburgh Penguins play in Nashville on Saturday night.
Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman reported that the Senators are interested in Penguins forwards Rickard Rakell and Bryan Rust. There's no indication Karlsson was the reason for Staios' visit, but with Pittsburgh open for business, the possibility of a reunion is intriguing.
For years, a Karlsson return has been a pipe dream for Senators fans who miss his glory days in the nation's capital.
Now, with Ottawa sitting atop the Atlantic Division, the idea is more tempting than ever.
There are pros and cons, so let's dive in.
The Pros of Bringing Back Erik Karlsson
For all the crushing hits, lost teeth and fights in the game of hockey, it can still be romantic.
A Karlsson return to Ottawa would be one of the feel-good stories of the NHL season, generating headlines while likely boosting ticket and jersey sales.
But nostalgia alone isn't a good enough reason to make a trade.
On the ice, Karlsson remains an electric offensive talent, especially on the power play.
At 36 years old, he's leading the Penguins in scoring with 19 points in 22 games, including eight on the power play.

And that's an area where Ottawa desperately needs help.
The Senators currently sit last in the NHL on the power play. As good as this team has been, there are still times when it lacks elite offensive creativity outside of Tim Stützle.
Would Karlsson supplant Jake Sanderson on the first power-play unit? Who knows? Figure that out later.
The Senators rank 14th in goals per game this season, which is good but not great. It's hardly a hot take to suggest Ottawa would score more goals with Erik Karlsson in the lineup.
And there's the opportunity for Karlsson to chase a Stanley Cup with the organization where his NHL career began.
The Senators are among the NHL's top teams and appear to be only a piece or two away from becoming legitimate Cup contenders.
For Karlsson, a return to Ottawa could offer the chance to add another chapter to a remarkable career and perhaps finish some unfinished business.
There's also the question of acquisition cost.
Karlsson is 36 years old and playing out the final season of his contract. His no-movement clause gives him considerable control over his future, potentially limiting Pittsburgh's options if it decides to trade him.That could work in Ottawa's favour, although the Penguins would still have to agree to the deal.
The bigger obstacle is money.
Karlsson carries a $10-million cap hit, meaning Pittsburgh would likely have to retain a significant portion of his salary. Moving André Burakovsky's contract could also help Ottawa make the numbers work.
It's complicated, but not necessarily impossible.
There have also been suggestions that Thomas Chabot could help Karlsson fit into the current dressing room, although it's difficult to know how a reunion would affect the team's chemistry.
Ultimately, the Senators could still use more firepower.
And Erik Karlsson is exactly that, with a fairy-tale storyline attached.
The Cons of Bringing Back Erik Karlsson
Now comes the part where the head takes over from the heart.
First off, the Senators appear to have a much greater need at forward than on defence.
That's why Staios has been linked to Rakell and Rust as potential solutions for Ottawa's top-six forward group.
Adding another scoring winger would address an obvious weakness. Bringing in Karlsson would create an entirely different set of questions.
For starters, where does he fit?
Pairing Karlsson with Jake Sanderson sounds exciting in theory, but would it work in practice?
Karlsson has never been known primarily for his defensive play, and the Senators have built much of their success around a suffocating defensive structure under Travis Green.
Do you really want to split up Thomas Chabot and Jordan Spence, a pairing that continues to tilt the ice mightily in Ottawa's favour?
Even Tyler Kleven and Nikolas Matinpalo have developed into a very good bottom pair.
The Senators have a strong blueline. Disrupting it to accommodate a 36-year-old offensive defenceman would be a gamble.
And that's before considering the assets required to acquire him.
Ottawa has limited trade capital, and every asset spent on Karlsson is one that can't be used to address the team's more pressing need for scoring help up front.
Karlsson is also a rental, with his contract expiring at the end of the season.
If the Senators wanted to keep him beyond this year, there's no guarantee he would come cheaply, even with a hometown discount similar to the one Claude Giroux accepted.
Then there's the defensive side of Karlsson's game.
Even at his peak, Karlsson was prone to defensive gaffes. He could create something spectacular at one end of the ice and surrender an opportunity at the other.
That's the trade-off with a high-risk, high-reward player.
The analytics bear that out.

Positive in the top left indicates the offence a player creates when on the ice, and the red in the bottom left indicates chances allowed defensively when on the ice.
Karlsson continues to generate offence at an impressive rate, but his defensive results raise questions about how he would fit into Ottawa's system.
The Senators currently rank sixth in expected goals allowed, according to Natural Stat Trick.
That's no small accomplishment, and it's a major reason they've been so successful this season.
Would Karlsson's offensive contributions outweigh the defensive opportunities he might surrender?
It's a fair question.
The Senators have worked hard to become a team that doesn't need to outscore its mistakes to win hockey games.
Bringing in Karlsson could threaten some of that balance.
The Verdict
There's no denying that Karlsson returning to Ottawa would be a lot of fun.
The ovations, the familiar No. 65 jersey and the chance to watch one of the most electrifying players in franchise history make another run at the Stanley Cup would be must-see TV.
But the most fun outcome for Senators fans this season would be watching their team win as many hockey games as possible.
And that should be the priority.
Ottawa already has an excellent defensive group and a system that is producing results. What it needs most is another forward who can put the puck in the net.
Karlsson could help the Senators score more goals, but would he make them a better team?
That's where the debate gets complicated.
The return of the King could have a fairy-tale ending or become a Shakespearean tragedy.
Either way, it would be must-see TV.
